Choose Language

GLOBAL LEADERSHIP FORECAST 2023

04.

Confidence in Leadership Takes a Nosedive

Share on LinkedIn
A Crisis of Trust in Leadership Hybrid Work Doesn't Deliver Its Promise

BY THE NUMBERS

Leader Quality Ratings Reflect Biggest Drop in a Decade

A large graph

A Crisis of Faith in Company Leaders Hits as Managers Burn Out

Though it is often short-lived, crisis can be a defining moment in leadership. In 2020, while the world grappled with unprecedented challenges, we saw a spike in confidence in leadership quality as employees trusted leaders to guide them.

But as frequently occurs after a crisis, exhaustion and cynicism have set in. Today, only 40% of leaders report that their company has high-quality leaders. This represents a significant drop from two years ago, and measures closer to levels during the wake of the economic crisis in the early 2010s.

Signs of burnout are growing among leaders, with 72% reporting that they often feel used up at the end of the day, an increase from 60% in 2020.

While leaders struggle to maintain the trust and confidence of their teams, they also face internal challenges. Signs of burnout are growing among leaders, with 72% reporting that they often feel used up at the end of the day, an increase from 60% in 2020. Additionally, leaders are deeply concerned about burnout on their teams, with only 15% feeling prepared to prevent employee burnout.

The result is a perfect storm: as leadership exhaustion sets in, employees have rising expectations of their leaders. Companies need to create models for high-quality leadership that will engage and retain employees while not overburdening already struggling leaders.

Data Dive

People Icon

Only 15% of leaders feel prepared to prevent employee burnout

WHERE TO FOCUS

Define a High-Quality Leadership Culture

Leadership quality ratings are closely intertwined with company culture. As a result, high-quality leadership may look different in every organization.

However, among organizations that have the highest quality rankings for their leaders, there are five key strategies HR puts in place:

  • They develop leaders in critical leadership skills.
  • They employ people-forward talent practices focused on development and career growth.
  • They implement a common leadership model and strategy across the organization.
  • They offer high-quality development across their entire pipeline of leaders.
  • They focus on promoting leaders internally more than hiring from the outside.

Organizations that are already succeeding with these practices have an average of 42% more high-quality leaders than their peers. They are also 3.4X times more likely to be rated a best place to work by their leaders.

While high-quality leadership may look different depending on company culture, we found some common ground in how leaders described great leadership in their own words. Across all industries and cultures, empathy dominated leaders’ perceptions of great leadership as well as how leaders model good behaviors by examples.

BY THE NUMBERS

How Nearly 14,000 Leaders Define What Makes a Great Leader

A large graph

Data Dive

People Icon

Companies implementing best practices to develop their leaders are 3.4X more likely to be rated a best place to work

A Crisis of Trust in Leadership Hybrid Work Doesn't Deliver Its Promise

Download

Get your copy of the report.

Download a full PDF of Global Leadership Forecast 2023.

Get the 2023 Report